vs Story – Dante’s Inferno and Sartre’s No Exit
This essay is on setting differences using
the works of Dante’s The Inferno and Jean Paul Sartre’s No Exit.
Adam looks about spotting all the important
people that will influence the rest of his life. He takes a deep breath
and prepares to make this his last and final addition to life. Quietly
he draws back from the church as if to stop time, this moment may define
him as a man. He turns to look at the priest as if to reply his answer,
but suddenly he realizes the hand he is holding is as cold as death. Quickly
he snaps back into reality recognizing he is not asking for his bride’s
hand in marriage, but burying her. Once again his mind tricked him into
thinking that he was starting all over again with a new chance; however,
as in life, sometimes there are no second chances.
Dante’s Inferno and Jean Paul Sartre’s
No Exit illustrate irony in setting in similar ways, such that there are
no second chances in life. Both works take the readers into the minds of
their authors where each author gives their interpretation of hell. Dante’s
and Jean Paul Sartre’s works both have similar aspects of setting that
are expressed in similar styles. Through symbolism, representation, and
finite physical details each author establishes
irony, yet also reinforces his theme.
When Dante wrote The Inferno his mind thrived on the different levels of
interpretation; likewise, Jean Paul Sartre’s mind thrived on this, and
he patterned No Exit after Dante’s work.
The symbolism expressed in Dante’s Inferno
correlates directly, in some cases, to the play written by Jean Paul Sartre,
No Exit. Symbolism in both works cannot be defined by one level of thinking
and neither can it be comprehended on one level. However, symbolism in
relation to the setting of both works exhibits the nature of both writers
to be very ironic in some cases. For example, throughout Dante’s Inferno,
Dante makes many direct references to the light and the heavens: “Therefore,
if you win through this gloomy pass and climb again to see the heaven of
stars when it rejoices to you . . .” (p. 145, l. 82 -5).These references,
also made in No Exit, reveal the irony that none of the inhabitants of
hell can ever see the light of God or, in Jean Paul Sartre’s perspective,
will always be reminded of the light and the choice they made: “Always
broad daylight in my eyes- and in my head.” (p.6) is another example of
ironic symbolism, the mantle, found in No Exit and the evident references
to heaven and the “true way” The Inferno.
Additionally, “Yes, now’s the moment; I’m
looking at this thing on the mantlepiece, and I understand that I’m in
hell.”(p. 45): this direct quote from the play No Exit also captivates
Dante’s exact meanings that while you are in hell you will constantly be
reminded of the
path you chose not to take or the “true
way” you chose not to follow. Finally the last illustration of symbolism
in No Exit is the mirror and in Dante’s Inferno the creatures of hell.
The mirror, or the lack of, reveals the character’s weaknesses towards
themselves. The character of Estelle had six mirrors in her lifetime and
now is sentenced in hell never to see herself again. While for the other
characters, Inez and Gracin, the lack of mirrors represents something else.
For Gracin he sees mirrors everywhere, and this shows the torture he goes
through in hell, being constantly reminded of his sins. On the other hand,
for Inez her mirror is seeing Estelle, her object of desire, and Gracin
together forever, while also being constantly reminded of the sin, lust,
she committed on earth. Dante’s work is much more
representative, and his creatures of hell
disclose their symbolism in the guarding of the different circles of hell.
For example the Minotaur, once a great beast who guarded many, is now guardian
of circle seven and will forever be reminded of his sins on earth due to
the fact his is the guardian of those who can never escape and his presence
is a struggle of unending hell. The sins of hell in The Inferno and No
Exit both exemplify the notion that
the sin you committed on earth is also
the punishment you shall receive in hell. This notion is the basis of the
irony, that what you could not live without on earth is the