I think that the book The Giver by Lois Lowry is a book that shows that it isnt good to be perfect or live in a perfect world. You don’t get to experience many things that you experience in regular life. One example from the book is how Jonas doesn’t like the job that the elders assigned to him. He didnt know what he was supposed to do as a giver. He wished he had a regular job like his friends had.
I hate someone assigning me my job in the community. I would want to be able to pick my own role, even if we both agreed on the same thing. Another reason the book shows how perfection is not good is how the life is so dull in Jonass world. Nobody sees any color.
In my opinion, color makes the world very beautiful. Everybody must follow strict laws. If a citizen does not abide by these rules, they are sent to prison and singled-out from the world. Also, they never meet anyone outside their town like regular people would at colleges or on vacation. Besides the festivals when kids grow another year, nothing very exciting goes on in the towns.
Most importantly, there was almost no point to living. The only things that they did were grow up, get a job, and own kids you didn’t even give birth to. Your life is controlled by a group of people that you don’t see too much of. You don’t experience any strange feelings like excitement or jealousy. Also, I think that the most important source of learning for a person is learning from there own experiences.
People should learn from their own experiences in real life, but people don’t in Jonas world. As you can see, a perfect town or community isnt that good. The quest for perfection can cause many problems.
